Office-Politics

What is OfficePolitics.com? Real People. Real Problems. Expert Advice.

The Office-Politics Advisers:

John Burton Franke James Marty Seldman Glueck Bezoza Rick Brandon Arnie Herz Timothy Johnson erika andersen

Archived Letters | OP Advisers | Bookstore | Office-Politics Game | About | RSS


Franke James
The irreverent
Co-creator of Office-Politics will wade in with her opinion on your dilemma, and seek advice from industry experts.

.

Dr. John Burton teaches Ethics at the Schulich School of Business at York University in Toronto, Canada

Do I have any rights to find out who evaluated me,
making me lose my post and my raise?

May 2004
Dr. John Burton, ethicist, mediator, lawyer and theologian answered this letter for Office-Politics. His passion is helping people and organizations create better relationships and stronger communities by being clear, committed and collaborative in their approach to ethics and conflict.

Dear Office-Politics,

I do security at a plaza in downtown Los Angeles. I used to work in the lobby, which is the highest paid post. I, along with a coworker, lost that post because a tenant did an evaluation. I would like to know -- Do I have any rights to find out who evaluated me making me lose my post and my raise?

Another question, can my boss call me a bad names and tell me that I am fat?

Sincerely,

InSecurity

Dear InSecurity,

If you are a member of a union they will be able to answer your question about what is appropriate in an evaluation. If you aren't in a union your employer should still have a written policy setting out how they will do evaluations. Read through that in order to see whether you have been evaluated according to that policy. If not, then you have grounds to complain to your employer for breaching terms of employment.

In all likelihood, however, you are like most security guards who work for firms that take advantage of the powerlessness of their employees and so mistreat them. Certainly your second question indicates that this is the case. Such companies may not have any evaluation policy, or may feel that they are not obliged to follow them, since there are no consequences if they don't.

Unfortunately they are pretty safe in that assumption. Unless you are prepared to begin to organize a union to empower you and fellow employees who are mistreated, you don't have a lot of capacity to call your employer to account. You might try consulting a labour lawyer to see if there is something in California law that can help you as well.

As for your employer calling you bad names and telling you that you are fat, that is absolutely unacceptable. There's little you can do, however. Try looking for another employer.

Good luck to you,

Dr. John


Send your comments about this article to: ceo AT officepolitics DOT com

The Ethics Letters that appears as a feature of this Website is an educational and discussion oriented column designed to help the reader better understand ethical issues. The matters discussed in the letter are reviewed in a summary/abbreviated way and are only meant to foster thinking on the part of the reader. If a person decides to adopt or implement suggestions, they do so at their own risk. No representation or warranty is provided in relation to suggestions or the contents of the letter. Neither the authors of the letter, Franke James, John W. Burton, or the owners of this Website accept any liability whatsoever for any opinions expressed in the letter or for errors and omissions. Submission of letters to the Office-Politics Forum grants the Publisher, Nerdheaven Ltd. the right to reproduce, republish, repurpose and excerpt the submission in any and all other media, without compensation or contacting the author. Copyright Nerdheaven Ltd. 2002-2005